# Effective Debugging

## Introduction

This vignette will guide you through the primary debugging workflow in `{rixpress}`, covering how to:

1. Inspect the error messages from a failed build.
2. Trace the dependency graph to find structural problems.
3. Isolate specific parts of the pipeline for focused debugging.
4. Access logs from previous builds to investigate regressions.

## The First Response to a Failed Build: `rxp_inspect()`

Imagine you have just run `rxp_make()` and are greeted with an error message in your console.

    Build process started...

    + > mtcars building
    + > mtcars_am building
    + > mtcars_head building
    x mtcars_head errored
    ✓ mtcars built
    ✓ mtcars_am built
    ! pipeline completed [2 completed, 1 errored]
    Build failed! Run `rxp_inspect()` for a summary.

The build has failed. Your immediate next step should always be to run `rxp_inspect()`. By default, this function reads the most recent build log, which in this case is the one from our failed run.

    rxp_inspect()

This will return a data frame summarizing the status of every derivation in the pipeline. Let’s look at a hypothetical output:

           derivation build_success                                               path    output
    1 all-derivations         FALSE /nix/store/j5...-all-derivations       mtcars_head
    2       mtcars_am          TRUE /nix/store/a4...-mtcars_am                  mtcars_am
    3     mtcars_head         FALSE                                      <NA>          <NA>
    4          mtcars          TRUE /nix/store/b9...-mtcars                       mtcars
                                                  error_message
    1                                                      <NA>
    2                                                      <NA>
    3 Error: function 'headd' not found\nExecution halted\n
    4                                                      <NA>

The two most important columns for debugging are `build_success` and `error_message`.

- `build_success`: This `TRUE`/`FALSE` column immediately tells you which derivation failed. In our example, `mtcars_head` is the culprit.
- `error_message`: This column contains the standard error output captured from the Nix build process. It provides the exact reason for the failure. Here, the message `"Error: function 'headd' not found"` points to a simple typo in our R code.

By pinpointing the specific derivation and providing the raw error message, `rxp_inspect()` eliminates guesswork and directs you straight to the source of the problem.

## Investigating Structural Issues with `rxp_trace()`

Sometimes, a pipeline fails not because of a typo in a single derivation, but because of a logical error in how the derivations are connected. `rxp_trace()` is the tool for diagnosing these structural issues. It reads the pipeline’s dependency graph (`dag.json`) and helps you answer questions like:

- “What steps must run before this one?” (Dependencies)
- “If I change this step, what other steps will be affected?” (Reverse Dependencies)

For instance, if `mtcars_mpg` is producing an unexpected result, you can trace its lineage:

    rxp_trace("mtcars_mpg")

This might return:

    ==== Lineage for: mtcars_mpg ====
    Dependencies (ancestors):
      - filtered_mtcars
        - mtcars*

    Reverse dependencies (children):
      - final_report

    Note: '*' marks transitive dependencies (depth >= 2).

This output clearly shows that `mtcars_mpg` depends directly on `filtered_mtcars` and indirectly (transitively) on `mtcars`. It also shows that `final_report` depends on it. If you expected `mtcars_mpg` to depend on a different intermediate object, this trace would immediately reveal the mistake in your pipeline definition.

Calling `rxp_trace()` without any arguments will print the entire dependency tree, which is useful for getting a high-level overview of your project’s structure.

You could instead plot the DAG using `rxp_ggdag()` for example, but if the project is large, reading the DAG could be difficult. `rxp_trace()` should be more useful in these cases.

## A Proactive Strategy: Isolating Derivations with `noop_build`

When debugging or prototyping, you often need to make frequent changes to an early step in your pipeline. If a slow, computationally expensive derivation depends on this changing step, your development cycle can become painfully slow. Because Nix’s caching is based on inputs, any change to an upstream step will invalidate the cache for all downstream steps. Imagine a pipeline where you are tuning a data preprocessing step, which is then followed by a lengthy model training process:

    list(
      # We are actively changing the filter condition in this step
      rxp_r(
        name = preprocessed_data,
        expr = filter(raw_data, year > 2020)
      ),
      # This step takes hours to run
      rxp_r(
        name = expensive_model,
        expr = run_long_simulation(preprocessed_data)
      ),
      rxp_rmd(
        name = final_report,
        rmd_file = "report.Rmd" # Depends on expensive_model
      )
    )

In this scenario, every time you adjust the filter() condition in preprocessed_data, Nix correctly invalidates the cache for expensive_model. This means the hours-long simulation will be re-triggered with every small change, making it impossible to iterate quickly on the preprocessing logic. This is the perfect use case for noop_build = TRUE. By applying it to the expensive downstream step, you temporarily break the dependency chain:

    list(
      # We can now change this step as much as we want
      rxp_r(
        name = preprocessed_data,
        expr = filter(raw_data, year > 2020)
      ),
      # This and all downstream steps will be skipped
      rxp_r(
        name = expensive_model,
        expr = run_long_simulation(preprocessed_data),
        noop_build = TRUE
      ),
      rxp_rmd(
        name = final_report,
        rmd_file = "report.Rmd" # Also becomes a no-op
      )
    )

Now, when you run `rxp_make()`, `preprocessed_data` will build as normal. However, `expensive_model` will resolve to a no-op build, and because `final_report` depends on it, it will also become a no-op. This allows you to rapidly iterate on and validate the `preprocessed_data` logic in isolation, without waiting for the simulation to run. Once you are satisfied with the preprocessing, simply remove `noop_build = TRUE` to re-enable the full pipeline and run the expensive model training with your finalized data.

## Historical Debugging: Going Back in Time

When iterating quickly, it might be useful to compare results to the ones obtained from previous runs. It is possible to check results from previous runs using the logs.

First, use `rxp_list_logs()` to see the build history:

    rxp_list_logs()

                                                            filename   modification_time size_kb
    1 build_log_20250815_113000_a1b2c3d4e5f6g7h8i9j0k1l2m3n4o5p6.rds 2025-08-15 11:30:00    0.51
    2 build_log_20250814_170000_z9y8x7w6v5u4t3s2r1q0p9o8n7m6l5k4.rds 2025-08-14 17:00:00    0.50

You can see a successful build from yesterday (`20250814`). To find out the differences with today’s results, you can inspect that specific log by providing a unique part of its filename to `which_log`:

    # Inspect yesterday's successful build log
    rxp_inspect(which_log = "20250814")

This allows you to compare yesterday’s build summary with today’s one. Furthermore, you can use `rxp_read()` with `which_log` to load the actual artifact from the previous run, which is invaluable for comparing data or model outputs across different versions of your pipeline.

    # Load the output of `mtcars_head` from yesterday's build
    old_head <- rxp_read("mtcars_head", which_log = "20250814")

## Conclusion

Debugging in `{rixpress}` is a systematic process supported by a powerful set of tools. By following this workflow, you can efficiently resolve issues in your pipelines:

- For runtime errors, start with `rxp_inspect()` to find the failed derivation and its error message.
- For logical or structural errors, use `rxp_trace()` to understand the dependencies.
- To speed up iteration, use `noop_build = TRUE` to isolate the part of the pipeline you are working on.
- For regressions, use `rxp_list_logs()` and the `which_log` argument to travel back in time and compare results.